Rock Identifier: Stone ID icon
USEducation

Rock Identifier: Stone ID评价分析

Next Vision Limited · 更新于 2026/06/20 02:53

本页基于 App Store 用户评价缓存生成,面向产品分析、竞品研究和搜索引用场景,保留评论证据并用 DeepSeek flash 提炼可行动信号。

App Store

缓存评论

160

差评占比

23%

好评占比

70%

模型

deepseek-v4-flash

摘要

Rock Identifier 综合评分3.9,但负面评价占23.1%。用户普遍抱怨识别准确率低、免费扫描次数少(每天仅2次)以及订阅收费不透明。产品机会在于改进核心识别算法并优化免费体验,以平衡正负面口碑。

Problem

核心痛点

3

识别准确率差

大量用户反馈同块石头多次扫描结果不同,或基本宝石也识别错误。

扫描同一石头三次得到三种不同结果

免费扫描次数太少

每天仅2次免费扫描,限制了体验和好奇心。

只能拍两张照片,想要更多就得付费

订阅收费不透明

免费试用7天后自动扣款,取消困难,甚至有欺诈性收费。

免费试用后直接扣款,找不到取消途径

Opportunity

产品机会

3

优化识别算法

改善对纹理和材质的识别,减少颜色误导,提高准确率。

建议更注重纹理而不是颜色

调整免费策略

增加每日免费扫描次数(如5次),或提供低价月卡选项。

希望每天至少能扫描5次

改进客服与退款

提供明确的取消订阅路径和在线客服,解决误扣款问题。

找不到联系方式和取消订阅入口

Strength

正向信号

3

识别准确率受肯定

部分用户认为准确率高达90%,尤其对抛光宝石和常见石头有效。

准确率大约85%-90%

寓教于乐

适合儿童和家庭亲子活动,激发对岩石的兴趣。

和女儿一起在溪边找石头的好工具

专业辅助价值

为考古、珠宝鉴定等专业领域提供快速参考。

用于考古和生物野外调查,准确率90%

Audience

用户分层

3

业余爱好者与家庭

主要是儿童、亲子用户,希望免费体验更多扫描。

想和女儿一起开始新爱好,但免费限制让人失望

收藏家与专业用户

有大量石头需要鉴定,愿意付费但要求准确度高。

有100多块石头,扫描结果必须可靠

珠宝买家/卖价者

用于区分真伪及估价,对识别误差敏感。

检测戒指上的宝石是真还是假

Risk

版本风险

2

2.19.2负面率偏高

该版本下负面评论集中,识别问题和付费争议突出。

几乎所有负面评论均为2.19.2版本

未修复历史问题

长期存在的准确率和收费问题未见改善。

使用两个月依然识别错误,每张照片结果不同

Action

行动建议

3

提升识别模型

引入更多纹理、结构特征训练,减少颜色依赖。

多次扫描同块石头结果各异,需更稳定的算法

增加免费扫描次数

将每日免费次数从2次提升至5次或更多,降低付费门槛。

每天只能扫2次,不够用

透明化订阅流程

试用期前明确提示自动续费,并提供一键取消方式。

试用后直接扣款,且无法方便取消

评论证据

80 条精选样本

Does not work

2.19.2 · 2026/06/18 04:00 · dennisbergan

1

Every Emerald I take a picture of, it identifies as aquamarine….

Only 2 free scans a day!!

2.19.2 · 2026/06/15 00:32 · Hlc82

1

I seen the ad and was excited to start a new hobby with my daughter, going to our creek and hunting for cool rocks. I don’t think there is a word for how disappointed I was to find such a small limit. Should be more upfront about what you get for free. I feel the reviews and such are so misleading.

Waste of time and money

2.19.2 · 2026/06/14 20:05 · MLHeli

1

This is for beginners possibly. Out of all the photos I asked for it to identify, it guessed ALL of them WRONG.

Not very accurate

2.19.2 · 2026/06/14 15:55 · Pear cheaters

2

I was trying to identify some of my rocks but knew most but the app kept identifying as same thing! Sorry deleted!

Opal-Labradorite mix

2.19.2 · 2026/06/12 00:48 · Nick47853

2

When I shine a stone that has a rainbow shine, it either THINKS it’s blue or purple when it’s actually red, orange, yellow, and green too

Subscription to Identify Rocks? Seriously?

2.19.2 · 2026/06/11 17:37 · MissEileen33

1

You get 2 free identifications before you hit a paywall. Another subscription to try and take your money!

You’re kidding, right

2.19.2 · 2026/06/11 15:32 · Jimmy Lee Dean

1

I subscribed to the app for one year. I canceled my subscription because I got tired of it getting the identification wrong. I tested this app on rocks that I knew exactly what they were. Most of the time it is incorrect. Again, you’re kidding, right? You actually want me to renew a subscription to an app that never works? You are out of their stinking minds!

fraud

2.19.2 · 2026/06/11 05:41 · tucsoncactus

1

not free. Credit card trap I was expecting advertisement per stone. But literally it's seven days and we got your credit card and you forget to cancel well we'll just keep billing you and trust us we're a random little we would never steal your credit cards or sell your information

Not accurate

2.19.2 · 2026/06/10 15:33 · Steve Botker

1

Doesn’t really work, don’t use for gems or jewelry the numbers and ID are all wrong

So bad you should try th

2.19.2 · 2026/06/10 11:37 · Turn do

2

It literally made me pay money

Meh😒

2.19.2 · 2026/06/08 21:14 · KaylSalad2017

2

The app is OK but it could be better because I can only identify three rocks or else it makes me have to get the free trial to don’t want to so I had to delete the game and I get it back again I can’t do anything because I don’t wanna get the free trial I wish I could identify more rocks but I can’t because I don’t have the free trial and I don’t spend money on games. Please fix it.

This site sucks

2.19.2 · 2026/06/03 12:24 · marieq1227#

1

I cannot definitely rely on the result done by from this site. Will definitely discontinue my membership.

They don't have some rocks

2.19.2 · 2026/06/02 13:55 · elizareid

2

App could not identify nakauriite because it wasn't in its database... too expensive to not have every rock.

Pay to see

2.19.2 · 2026/06/01 13:59 · Spiritually_Awakend_2019

1

Have to pay to get right crystal name!!!!!! 😡

Inconsistent and a waste of money

2.19.2 · 2026/05/30 07:09 · Somegirl67812

1

I will scan the same rock, in the same conditions, from the same angle 3 times and it will tell me it’s a different rock every time. My daughter has the app on her phone as well and she will scan the same rock I did and also get a different result. 🤦‍♀️ With these types of results I feel like I could just use google image search for free. I already purchased the year subscription but will not purchase it again!

Help!!

2.19.2 · 2026/05/30 03:57 · Nena1274

2

The app charged me even if I canceled before the 7days of testing😡😣😖now I can’t pay those 43 $ and there is no where on the app that I can call nor write for help

Really bad

2.19.2 · 2026/05/29 19:21 · Cebarrrr

1

It identify rocks by their color. I took the jade photo it said it is emerald, it identify amazonite as turquoise. These are basic things and this app is bad even at this. I wouldn’t trust.

🤦🏻‍♂️

2.19.2 · 2026/05/26 04:00 · ALICEAJR

1

Couldn’t even recognize citrine

READ THIS FOR ALL DETAILS

2.19.2 · 2026/05/24 16:45 · read my review ☠️

2

Rock identifier is a games that kinda tries to really get you to pay money because if you do not pay you only get a few (like two i think) scans a day but if you pay you unlimited now i am not going to lie the scans are pretty cool though because they give what they mainly think it is and other possibilities (three more) and what you think and this is why i give it two stars

Doesn’t identify any stones

2.19.2 · 2026/05/22 15:48 · TWC70

1

I have tried to identify multiple types of gemstones and it doesn’t know. Then I tried to figure out how to cancel and I don’t see any way to contact them to cancel. They changed my account again.

This Rock-Hound needs some Readers

2.19.2 · 2026/05/20 23:41 · MitzaPlix

2

It purposely sets it up to make you think you need to pay for it. App mis-identified constantly. They want encouragement? How bout “Do better, Be better!”.

Stone

2.19.2 · 2026/05/20 21:04 · Now I see you

1

Doesn’t know red from purple or real from fake. Would like my money back.

ONLY GET TWO

2.19.2 · 2026/05/20 17:21 · mixtgal

1

this app is arse bc i have to pay to wrongly identify rocks. it didnt know if it was basalt or a fossil 😐😐

Premium is stupid

2.19.2 · 2026/05/18 19:16 · Pearl the scarlet macaw

1

I barely get anything on this app and I don’t have the money for premium. Some people really love rocks and either don’t have a lot of money or don’t have a job. So the premium thing is stupid, all the features should be available to everyone. Not just to people with more money.

Not precise

2.19.2 · 2026/05/16 11:42 · Vkatia1$

1

My circonio was tile like diamond

Changes its opinion a lot

2.19.2 · 2026/05/15 18:08 · Rutabagahoy

2

Take 3 pix of one rock from different angles and you will get 3 different decisions on what it is.

Never provide a specific answer

2.19.2 · 2026/05/13 18:12 · mdmfonbclqjconcs

1

I been using this app for now two months I even paid the 39.99 for the month, honestly not worth it at first I thought I was helping me but its only really good at identifying polished stones, as when presented with raw stones it provides different types of mineral or stone as I have taken multiple pictures of the same minerals/stones with most of them having different results in every picture! Not good app need improvement and more mineral/stones information.

Beware

2.19.2 · 2026/05/07 21:20 · Richthecunty

1

Started receiving spam calls after this app. And also had a fraudulent charge on my card 4 days later.

wasted 5 minutes of my life

2.19.2 · 2026/05/07 18:08 · llynux

1

makes you watch a long, poorly written intro only to reveal you need to pay for the app through a subscription service. Like girl just tell me ahead of time.

Not even remotely accurate

2.19.2 · 2026/05/04 22:24 · T.O…!!!

1

Please don’t waste your money this app was 100% wrong 100% of the time and I can’t even get my money back!

I thought this was free

2.19.2 · 2026/05/03 14:54 · Nat The Jellyfish

1

I went on the app super excited and then I took a picture of two rocks and then I couldn’t take a picture of anymore cause I had to get the subscription and I deleted it right afterwards, I do not recommend if you do not want to pay money.

I think you should make it so that you can take more pictures of the rock in a day

2.19.2 · 2026/04/29 02:11 · The soy sauce

1

I have so many rocks and I can only take a picture of two in a day

Not accurate

2.19.2 · 2026/04/27 17:14 · Xjsport

1

Not accurate at all, just based on pictures, telling me a cubic zirconia on 3 different attempts at the same stone is a sapphire, diamond and an emerald

Inaccurate waste of money

2.19.2 · 2026/04/25 19:54 · 0livia613

1

This app sounds great in theory, but is actually really terrible. It has misidentified stones as basic as rose quartz and amethyst. Please do not waste your money on this app.

Money

2.19.2 · 2026/04/13 03:18 · G* star

2

I don’t like that you have to pay. I thought this would be a great app that I could use to identify rocks but no. I have to pay and I only get 2 photos a day if I don’t get premium.

Fraud

2.19.2 · 2026/04/11 15:17 · MikeCustomer

1

This app will tell you you’ll get a 7 day free trial then once you accept they charge you 13.12 - Report this app

Owner

2.19.2 · 2026/04/10 21:07 · Funtrackers03

2

This is a great App just Love it !!

Mostly harmless

2.19.2 · 2026/06/17 17:41 · Sleeping now

4

This app is Vogon approved. Like well read poetry. It’s pretty darned good.

My stones

2.19.2 · 2026/06/17 16:50 · My sack of rocks

5

Mostly correct needs info pics to be accurate

Excellent

2.19.2 · 2026/06/17 01:37 · Fitzsr44

5

Incredibly easy to use and contains so many variations of rocks! I’m hooked!

Amazing

2.19.2 · 2026/06/16 18:36 · Da boys🏴‍☠️

5

I love it it’s fast it’s good for taking photos and I just started. This is the best app ever

The finder and emeralds it finds

2.19.2 · 2026/06/16 18:31 · Cmoneasye

5

It has a magnetic field that finds metal and special rocks have metal

Love it!!!

2.19.2 · 2026/06/16 16:02 · Leelalovesme

5

Great app

Okay

2.19.2 · 2026/06/15 21:02 · It is a okay app

4

It does not show how much money

Truly Valuable

2.19.2 · 2026/06/15 11:31 · DDYW58

5

I have many items to scan and had some surprises but in general this app has helped me decide on these items. Now I can estimate for my home owners policy

I have WIFI😭😭😭😭😭

2.19.2 · 2026/06/14 15:34 · BADDIE TEST

5

It says I don’t have WiFi I have 3 bars and cellphone tower internet so it’s a bug in the game or my phone is broken pls fix this I was looking forward to trying the app oh btw I put it as 5 stars so people could see but also cuz I think the app would have been fun if it would have loaded

Beach finds

2.19.2 · 2026/06/14 14:37 · JPMSG999

5

Helpful

This app is Amazing!

2.19.2 · 2026/06/14 02:03 · Mika MacBook

5

Excellent App!

Great app

2.19.2 · 2026/06/13 14:19 · Jeremiah T

3

This app is about 85% accurate there is a metal detector that works, an identify area for rocks, and an area for the price of the rocks. The only really bad part is you only can either scan 2 times and then you will have to wait a day to scan 2 more times. Or you can buy “ unlimited IDs”

The best app

2.19.2 · 2026/06/13 03:08 · Leticiapanah

5

I found a valuable rock it worth $2 to $15 dollars you should buy it and then look for a valuable rock

Pls read

2.19.2 · 2026/06/13 01:48 · tuhvfujnbgyk

3

It is good but u have to pay to know value otherwise good!🦷👅🎺

Rocks are cool

2.19.2 · 2026/06/12 14:17 · Foxyandcris

4

It’s good and honestly recommend for beginners but lighting is a big problem for me and sometimes it turns a green aventurine into a black agate because it mistakes the two from the lighting I feel like maybe you can fix this by making it a little more texture rather than color observant or maybe I have to use both of my daily things because of a mistake it made so maybe make a thing where we can get our daily searches back so we can do two rocks rather than 1 a day

You can use this free

2.19.2 · 2026/06/10 23:33 · BuggyMcBugBug

5

My favorite app. Look for the small cancel button in right hand corner, then use the camera button all for free. Check out the real vs fake feature! Catch them phony fakers. Lots of dyed fake turquoise out there, resin crackle quartz, and plastic Ethiopian opal.

Rock on

2.19.2 · 2026/06/10 13:47 · ctpartto

5

Great app. Very handy

Ayuda

2.19.2 · 2026/06/10 06:33 · Laromana8

5

Ayuda fácil para saber lo que tienes a mano.

Stoned Again

2.19.2 · 2026/06/09 23:37 · Rockn Roger

5

Hey guys, I love this site. As an amateur collector it helps to clear the fog ( so to speak ). Even when I’m pretty sure of what I have, going to this site is always good, whether I was right or wrong. This site has added so much to my enjoyment of our hobby, THANK YOU ! For being there. Keep up the good work! Your friend, Roger

On the rocks

2.19.2 · 2026/06/09 17:21 · Bad guess

3

Unfortunately not doing a good job. Your guess is as good as mine

Greg and sons stone arts, Effigies and more.

2.19.2 · 2026/06/09 00:36 · Terri1969

4

I hope you’re not telling me this is something and it’s nothing I’m hoping to sell some stones to a company and if you are correct with the identification of my stones I’ll write you up a letter of recommendation that will make you more profitable app. Thank you very much. I hope you are correct about the types of stones and other materials I have. We’re working on a catalog of stone art to show some beautiful pieces that is going to be for sale or for auction. If the price is right. Thank you.Have a great day. I hope I don’t get in trouble for doing this for you guys. They say I’m advertising for you guys. I’m not advertising.,? Thank you ., Greg

Useful and accurate

2.19.2 · 2026/06/08 19:17 · Tetonsareus

5

I work in archaeology and biology field surveys throughout the SW. and bit of a rock hound by nature. This thing is accurate about 90% of the time and has no real competitor. Is it perfect? No. But trying to ID rocks in the field is always tough. It’s why there’s always at least three choices. It’s great for semi precious stuff like turquoise, topaz, fire agate, peridot, azurite and fossils. It’s the best option you’ll find.

Mrs. R

2.19.2 · 2026/06/08 19:13 · Rizzerwon

5

This app is just a joy to work with. As I find my way through the gravel all over my property in MI, right in the middle of the mitten! Thanks!

Why only two

2.19.2 · 2026/06/07 22:07 · Moo moo nags the mags

4

So I got the app and it started out great but when I only did two rocks it told me I have to wait until tomorrow to do two other more rocks and if I ding want to i have to pay so four stars only because I wanted to do more then two rocks 😡

Giving a review.I use it quite often and enjoy finding out what I have.

2.19.2 · 2026/06/07 19:09 · Eve’s Honey

5

Love it I have numerous that I have collected over the years that I now know what they are. I am still collecting.

It could be better

2.19.2 · 2026/06/06 19:44 · jna8470

3

I think I like the app but it has limits and they don’t seem to be getting past them very much.

Great identifying aid

2.19.2 · 2026/06/06 17:26 · Saleen2015

5

I use the app often to identify stones, crystals, and purchases

Dis' is freakin' good for my rock collection!

2.19.2 · 2026/06/05 22:26 · he he me doppledanger

5

This is NOT about Plants Vs Brainrot, but this app is freakin'good! I have 100+ rocks in my collection and i,i,it has the RIGHT idenifcations.

Awesome!

2.19.2 · 2026/06/05 21:27 · Ollie Mex

5

I’ve always loved rocks but never knew what kind they were. Now, all the info is there for me!

hello :3

2.19.2 · 2026/06/05 13:26 · Ashton(; . ;)

5

its a great app but i js wish you didnt have to pay for more than like two scans a day but overall no complaints :)

Rock Idenification

2.19.2 · 2026/06/04 22:45 · Ashx/AshX

5

To start this review off, I’m just gonna say it’s amazing, it works really well! One thing I hope could improve is the amount of pictures you take when your not signed up, it limits curiosity for me and some other people that have it, if it could be maybe at least 5 at minimum that would be great!

So fun!

2.19.2 · 2026/06/04 00:08 · BLStoffer

5

Such a fun app! I have lots of jewelry, some with genuine stones and some with fake. Rock Identifier has gotten every stone correct except for one. It pegged a lab created diamond as genuine!

This is pretty good ig

2.19.2 · 2026/06/03 17:52 · Ok/ perfect

4

I hate how I can only do 2 pictures a day and I have a herkimer diamond which ig is a clear quartz idk anymore

Amazing

2.19.2 · 2026/06/03 17:20 · ggtbgirl

5

Awesome app identifies so precisely!

Amazing App

2.19.2 · 2026/06/03 15:04 · Style13

5

So worth the years price I use this app all the time

So good

2.19.2 · 2026/06/03 13:12 · Funny and nice report

5

I like this app so much it’s so cool

Love this app!

2.19.2 · 2026/06/02 23:31 · **Diane**

5

I really do love this app and I feel like it is accurate 99% of the time. I also like that they have a free version.

Great Resource

2.19.2 · 2026/06/01 20:46 · VeggieVal

5

I subscribe to this app for the crystal healing information. I know “entertainment purposes only.” Great app and indispensable to me. I use it daily.

La mejor app

2.19.2 · 2026/05/31 18:51 · La piedra inteligente

5

Puede identificar piedras gemas y etc

2

2.19.2 · 2026/05/31 15:38 · Mimi the cat is cra cra

4

I like this app so I can learn about rocks cause me and my sibs are totally into rocks and I want to what rock the are but why do I need to pay $40 a year just not scan 2 rocks why just why and then the 1 month one is $2 does that make sense. good bye for now

Four stars

2.19.2 · 2026/05/31 06:07 · Rubydragonlady

4

Somtimes apps could lie was I lied to no however I used google as well and I have a book of gemstones so it helps me with research also no offense which I’m genuine about it giving five stars seems like I’m not quite honest with the review I would make you have to pay Ngl I prefer to wright down on paper and keep a record book for it so yeah I’ll use the app still

Excelente

2.19.2 · 2026/05/31 04:53 · Claudia Cee

5

The best

GREAT

2.19.2 · 2026/05/30 00:50 · Rocrre

5

I was trying to find a good crystal identification app and this was the only good one.

这个页面如何用于 SEO?

稳定 URL、动态 TDK、结构化数据和更新时间让搜索引擎能理解每个 App 的评价主题。

这个页面如何被 AI 搜索引用?

页面提供摘要、证据、痛点和行动项,方便生成式搜索直接引用有来源的结论。

数据如何更新?

页面记录更新时间,可点击重新生成,重新抓取评论并覆盖缓存页面。