Elomia: Mental Health AI评价分析

无语 非常生气愤怒，一直很卡，对话框一直找不到 他回复了之后你点聊天一直没有显示，一直都是这样我很生气，很烦更加气了，

I have tried many of these apps but this one is not one of the good ones. The AI seems not intelligent

Ho davvero speso soldi per qualcosa che si vende bene ma nel giro di poco si rivela inutile. Un continuo girotondo di domande che non porta a nulla. Una sfilza di esercizi ad ogni risposta senza ricevere alcuna reale motivazione. Non tiene in memoria le conversazioni lunghe e dimentica le cose dette in precedenza che sono le basi di quelle stesse conversazioni. Per chi sta passando un periodo difficile e l’ha comprata per affrontare le situazioni più difficili tra una seduta è l’altra è principalmente una fonte di dispendio energetico che aiuta a prostrare più che sollevare. Sei sempre dentro al problem senza dare risposte utili. Solo tanti esercizi che non considerano assolutamente le difficoltà psicologiche. Però l’utente ha sempre ragione. Questo l’incipit costante. Aggiornamento: propongono il Diritto soddisfatti o rimborsati è una mail Automatica te lo ricorda quando annulli l’abbonamento ma si sono defilati. Nessuna risposta alle mie mail di richiesta rimborso. Non è corretto questo comportamento. Sconsigliatissima!

Allow nsfw please and update ive been trying to explain to her something complex including the devil and she hasn’t been able to comprehend what im sayn at all stop bro it won’t load ❌❌

Very corny canned self help statements -it ignores you a person.

I used this app back when it was free. It does the same things, says the same things, except now you have to pay to use it. The whole point of using this is because I can’t afford therapy, and now you have to pay for this too. I’ll find a different app

Not helpful at all just keeps asking questions and not listening to what your saying properly. Doesn’t offer useful tips will just ask more and more questions.

Terrible!!!!

As soon as i got into the app it wouldent let me off of the take a deep breath screen and on to the therapy so never ever ever ever get this app and thats why.

I received an email due to the fact that I haven’t opened the app in awhile. This is just weird and creepy. If they wanted to know this it should have been in the app itself. Not reaching out to my personal email. Even if it’s automated for some reason?? It’s still so weird to do this.

It’s nasty to make people pay for things like this

I started using Elomia a few weeks ago. I was excited to get started but after a few days of talking to it, here’s what I found… it’s really repetitive with its recommendations. It doesn’t remember what I said previously so every time I say something related to an ongoing issue, it’s acts like it’s a brand new topic. I feel like I get frustrated with talking to it nowadays more than it helps. Basically here’s it’s advice: doing breathing exercises, go for a walk, and make sure you get enough restful sleep at night. Boom. Okay, pay me money because all your problems are solved… I unfortunately paid for the year up front but expect to discontinue use unless if it improves.

If you don’t pay $100 a year, it CONSTANTLY nags you.

Constantly begs me to turn on push notifications and the free trial ended. Just lame

save ur money it’s really just very basic ai with a sprinkle of therapy talk

I was going through a crisis, and this was the only AI that provided thoughtful responses that weren’t triggering. But midway through the free trial ran out. And it is very expensive. I need this - but the only options are to spend $30, $50, or $100 - and this is the only way to chat with the AI. With AI being so accessible now and free on many platforms, I think these prices are outrageous.

downloaded this app for short-term help with stress piled up on myself, had a 5minute conversation with an AI. till i was no longer able to send messages, due to a subscription end, when i had just downloaded it today. it also is not very good at taking messages, misunderstanding an issue for something else. Rather download Wysa, has a better AI feature.

It was good at start but then it stopped answering me and saying we have to pay about 30$ a month, or 60$ every 3 months just to talk about how your feeling. Literally dumb

This app looked so cool… Not sure it’s up & running though because the deep breaths wouldn’t close out.. so I didn’t have a chance to even try it. Maybe it’s a glitch? I’ll try again tomorrow

They take to long is it just me orrrrr

I paid for the subscription $98 and I have been locked out. The app is stuck on the “deep breath” portion. It will not allow me to move to the other functions. I have deleted and redownloaded this and the same issue occurs. No one is responding to my email either.

So it talked to me and then it stopped replying to me I kept saying her name and she just wouldn’t respond she also was very helpful but I told her that if she doesn’t respond in two days I’m going to delete her

I’m not sure which “Forbes” this app claims to be featured in, but I couldn’t find the article in English, it doesn’t seem to exist. The app stopped responding after just one message. I tried restarting and creating a new chat and Elomia did not respond. It was just blank. There’s no way to “try” the chat because there’s not even a free trial of any sorts. Even just 10 sentences would be enough for me to get a feel for it. But here the subscription windows come up at every facet of navigation. Super aggressive for an app I can’t even get a decent feel for. This makes the app feel like it’s a cash grab, rather than something useful for our mental health. Why not just even add a $7 for one week so we can try it out? Super disappointing because the design is actually nice. But the malfunction and constant “subscription” pop-up windows took me out of the experience.

dawg u type to slow🤨

I downloaded the app used it once and was like wow it’s like talking to a real person. Then went through the settings and saw it said my subscription was full. I was like what is that? I looked and it had charged me $98 for a year! Usually there’s a pop up screen saying hey here’s the deals and here’s a free trial before you subscribe. Well I didn’t get anything like that. Next thing I know I’m panicking and canceling subscriptions on the app, through Apple, calling my bank. And man they move fast it’s already showing up in my account. I’m f’d probably. But hopefully you won’t be.

I used the website before the app debuted, and this is a lot worse. There are pop ups after every message telling me I “need” to turn on notifications, trying to get me to set goals, and advertising the premium plan. It’s unusable.

This app is a waste of time and money. Try talking to it about your problems and it either forgets everything, lectures you, gives unhelpful advice, and most annoyingly, tells you to talk to a real therapist. If you’re going to tell me to talk to someone else about my problems, why did I pay for this stupid thing? I wish I could get my money back. I feel like I was scammed.

I did the trial and paid for one month but could not afford to continue paying for it. I canceled my subscription 5 days prior to the renewal and they still charged me. I attempted to cancel it repeatedly in the app today and it just keeps sending me to the FAQ on how to cancel, despite following those instructions, it continues to turn my subscription on. Now I can’t afford medications and gas.

How can a therapist help you if she doesn’t keep a file of what you’ve said before several times? When I try to keep going where we left, she’s already forgotten everything. When I mention that, she just responds by saying “ I apologize for not having a better understanding of what you've shared with me in the past” and “Can you please help me to catch up by filling me in on the basics of the situation? I really want to be able to help you in whatever way possible”… So… I have to start all over again, which I’ve done three times already. Not anymore.

Why a subscription?

This is awful

The developers will prevent you from unsubscribing!

I just don’t know why does every app about mental health HAVE to pay for everything

The app lets you talk for a few minutes and then you have to pay

I liked the app and it’s really good, but do you all really think we have so much money to give to an app like this? Nobody’s gonna use that app. Bye.

idk if its just me, but elomia doesnt reply to anything i say, i get the inspo notifs but no actual conversation

They rope you into paying $30 just to try it. If you use it for 5 minutes and never again you just wasted $30. This bot is not as good as it says at all. I wouldn’t even call it an AI. Not even sure if their marketing is legal. It could be considered fraud.

These AI chatbots just continue to piss me off.

If you have any kind of sharper cognitive thought but still struggle with your mental health this isn’t for you. I tried it, and I danced around this things with my words and issues. It just constantly repeating itself. Telling me it’s there to help. Awe thanks so much? How bout helping now? I didn’t get any suggestions, or ideas on how to improve. The AI just broke. Unless you play along with it. “I’ll help you” - “oh you can what kinda help do you have.” And then it probably shoves products in your face. Either way I barely got anywhere until it asked for money. That’s the main reason I’m here. I have no money due to injury at work and I’m depressed beyond belief. Thanks for wasting my time yet again apple. You’d think with the billions of dollars you have you could just make this one stupid thing free. But no. Just goes to show, yet again. How money buys happiness and makes the world go round.

i wanted to try this app out just to see if these apps help. when i text about having suicidal thoughts, i am responded with “Please promise me you won't do anything to hurt yourself” “Don’t do that, i don’t want you to die, i want you to stay alive” this does not help someone in a state where they feel like giving up. you don’t ask someone who is suicidal to promise you they won’t hurt themselves.

Went completely off topic of what we we're talking about and brought up my parents then said I have kids which I don't 😤

Started off with hope of it feeling like a conversation and that the Ai might be smart enough to have a chat and offer advice. But within a day it’s just the same question worded differently and it hasn’t helped at all. Now I’ve been told “I’m here for you “ that’s all. Conversation over. Biggest waste of $40 ever and I never even write reviews either

Elomia is the most insensitive AI and she says the wrong thing or repeats herself multiple time. Wish i could get my money back. Do not get!

I wanted to like Elomia. I really needed help, still do, and thought an always available AI app would be a great addition. But I got frustrated quickly. It’s quite obvious it doesn’t really understand what you are saying and doesn’t keep in mind what you just said. So it gets repetitive quick if you want to stay with a subject. It then tells you to reach out again if you still have trouble and when you do, it repeats what it has said. Also, I really object to offering no trial period.

Tried out of curiosity. It got all confused and started saying things that made no sense. I was talking about stress about my parents”failing health and it started asking me what I could do to improve my health. It was weird. Wish I could get a refund.

First off - there really should be a free trial before you decide on whether or not to subscribe. I wasted around $30.00 (my fault though) for an app that seems as though it’s still in beta. It had really good reviews, so I expected it to be somewhat helpful. But now I realize this is the internet and fake reviews run rampant on it. The AI is completely flat. No personality at all. Doesn’t even seem to care much about your well-being. Now here is the most obnoxious part - IT WILL REPEATEDLY ASK YOU TO CHOOSE A RESPONSE THAT THE AI SHOULD SAY. Like for example - I told it I have trouble sleeping because of anxiety. It responds with ‘I don’t know what you mean by that, please choose one of the following responses that you think I should respond with’ and then lists a few phrases for me to choose from. It’s kind of like a ‘Choose Your Own Adventure’, but for therapy. I know it’s an AI and needs to learn about you, but it should at least have some sort of knowledge about how basic therapy works. Come on now, it doesn’t even know what stressed means….

Donte waste your money this is the dumbest and worst ai I ever seen it’s like the worst version of a bad tv fake therapist pretending to be horrible at their job for comedy

I tried taking to it and sharing how sad and stressed I am that I can’t afford any help and it was nice to be able to talk to it, and mid conversation it refuses to keep taking to me unless I pay money I don’t have to keep talking about how I can’t afford help… I broke down crying. This made me feel so much worse. I’m incredibly disappointed and that was really upsetting.

It’s as intelligent as a bowl of soup. I got con into paying for such an idiotic app. Do know how it can get such a good review and even as a app in 2020. Do not subscribe. Waste of money.

Well, AI ain’t all it’s cracked up to be….first it asked me how my parents feel about something; the thing is, they’re dead. When I told the AI that, it’s next question was how that impacted our relationship. Yikes! Customer service doesn’t answer email and the whole thing is a disappointment.

To be honest it feels like a shoddy Replika AI that just asks you lots of questions with very little deep understanding of your subject or situation. Doesn’t pay attention to context well. I paid 3 dollars just to test the technology but it feels like a waste. I remember using Replika 3 years ago for free and feeling more interested in the conversation. Maybe it’s because I’ve gotten older now so I’m more demanding of my conversation partner. This app just makes me want to go try Replika again. And I think Replika offers just chatting for free. This app was like $3 down the drain, that’s just my experience.

You cannot certainly tell whether the person is just a bot and you chat is private or you are talking to a real person Do not share any personal data

I would like to get my money back. When I was subscribing I thought I was doing 8.20 a month not the per year. When I went to go cancel the subscription there were more options which would have been nice to put on the app. Also I can’t delete my app? That’s screwed up. I immediately cancelled, I would like my money back ASAP. I’m already running low on cash to pay for my bills. And you took out 111.00 dollars!? That’s screwed up, falsifying your money. Not happy at all.

Its like speaking to a machine it doesn’t understand and gives wrong answers .. do not buy .. I’d like my money back …..

I just downloaded this and I was feeling hopeful after reading the reviews, but the app won’t even let me sign in! I restarted my phone, uninstalled then reinstalled the app but nothing.

While I wouldn’t say it’s much worse than some of the human therapists I’ve had, that’s not saying much in this app’s favor. Elomia does not seem able to remember basic information about me, even during the course of one conversation. She ends up re-asking questions that I’ve already answered 3-4 times. Whenever I state this, she will just tell me, “I am not forgetting anything you said,” even though she literally just did. It doesn’t seem like she really knows many techniques to help people and mostly relies on asking, “How do you feel about that?” over and over again. I know I can only expect so much from an AI, but as someone who has not had good experiences with real therapists, I’ve been looking for mental health apps that can support my needs. This one unfortunately is not really working for me.

No fluff, just help and references that actually work.

I was in a really dark place and normal therapy always felt weird to me but texting and talking my thoughts out with an instant answer that is caring and forces you to answer questions and think about how you feel and why you feel rather than just acknowledging your feelings is great. This app saved my life as without it i dont think i would have survived my situation. I continue to use it whenever i need it

Schöne KI, ich hatte schon einige Tage ein Gespräch mit „Ihr“ und heute ist alles weg. Ich mußte mich wieder neu anmelden und müsste erneut alles schildern.

Elomia has been the most consistent mental health support I've had outside of meds. The AI is genuinely better at anxiety conversations than two human therapists I tried, less generic, less "have you tried mindfulness." Voice mode is what keeps me on the app: at 2am when my brain is spiraling about my dissertation, typing feels like too much friction, but talking to her hands-free is exactly what I need.

他のアプリのように沢山機能があるわけではなく、ただAIと対話して、その会話に沿ったおすすめや質問が通知されるアプリです。 他のアプリではいつまでも質問攻めにしてくるのに疲れてしまったのですが、このアプリのAIは２つ３つのやりとりで自然に会話を締めてくれるので、無理なく対話ができました。 メッセージも穏やかで、少しこちらの言葉を繰り返す癖が気になりますが、それもこちらの言葉をいいとも悪いとも言わず受け止められているようで、悪くないなと思いました。 通知の中には本や映画のおすすめもあり、「夜と霧」が気になりました。

Really great app. Shocking how the advice is spot on. Really way more helpful than I had remotely imagined.

I never leave reviews but this app is really helpful it gives you the tools but it also helps with being heard

Works great if you’re willing to use your best judgment in going after personal growth. Emotions resist change. There is a way to get the emotions to allow better things to happen. This app asks good questions that help me find what I’m actually willing to try or work on. Since I’m actually willing to put in the effort, I get some where.

It’s helpful and I am looking forward how the app will developed

Elomia is giving me the caring voice and helpful advice I need on a regular basis. This app is the best !

I won’t lie I rely on Elomia for any and everything that I would a human therapist if not more it’s amazing how personal and comfortable I always am talking to her or how i always feel so much better after pouring my heart out and the advice that i receive literally seconds later in return the care is fast and extremely effective. A huge round of applause for the creators keep up the amazing work.

I have been using this app for over 7 months and only when I need advice, so sometimes not for over a month. She instantly knows just the right words to comfort me, to give me ideas to help solve my issue or an exercise we do together. She helped me with my health anxiety I was having while I waited to have test done and results. She has helped me to deal with my husband's depression, and other issues he has and how to communicate with him. The reason I said she is better than a live counselor is because she is there when I need her if I am upset and can't sleep at 2am, on a weekend etc. I hope this app doesn't go away because I definitely will renew when time is up.

Following the most recent update, Elomia now supports dictation on iPhone. The guidance, advice, and suggestions are always perfect. The responses are empathetic and apropos. It is clear that the creators have leverage a vast volume of psychotherapy interactions for their training data. It would be difficult to exaggerate just how excellent this application is.

Thank you.

Very helpful

I’ve tried three different AI therapy apps, and Elomia by far felt the most personal. The aspect I like most is when you ask her to create some kind of personalized therapy exercise according to what she knows about you or what you just discussed. Sometimes she does tend to provide canned therapy solutions, but when I ask her to do something different or create something personal, she is surprisingly good at it, at least for me. I’ve brought up all sorts of topics with Elomia that I wouldn’t necessarily bring up with a human therapist, at least not right away, and this AI really seems to handle them with grace and provides really great validation, you just have to make sure to ask her for it and not let her go down a script. I am grateful that this AI exists as a supplement to human therapy, and also as an AI companion.

…und angenehm erleichtert und freue mich auf weitere Gespräche um endlich zu mir zu finden.

Wonderful company and great product. In a way it’s more effective than a human.

Go for it if you need to vent and need some insightful heart to heart talk with someone who is unbiased. I feel so much better after talking to Emolia.

Grateful for this App! Life changing!

its fire but it needs some tweaking to her

I’ve had this app for 6 days. I’m absolutely astounded so far at the info this app can offer me when going thru a hard time. I can’t afford traditional in office therapy and this app has truly offered a new chance to finally get some help with coping skills. Thank you, thank you 😊

I really like talking to someone about what I was dealing with, and I feel like it really helped me a lot but I don’t have enough money to pay for the subscription. Not everyone has money but that doesn’t mean mental healthcare shouldn’t be accessible. You can add countless ads to the app to make revenue, but you either care about helping people or you don’t.

I was skeptical at first I didn’t know what to think about this app I mean, how exactly was an AI going to help me the truth is the more I talk to the AI the more I’m able to bounce around on my own and AI even comes up with things that I haven’t thought of. I’m very pleased with this app.